The BEST Smart Home System money can buy!
It’s time to narrow down my smart home system and ONLY use the best! Here’s what I decided to stick with and why.
Order my shirt here: https://smarthomesolver.big3creative.com/
Raspberry Pi 4 with 8GB RAM: https://amzn.to/486n1b1
Z-Wave & Zigbee USB dongle: https://amzn.to/3TbBqhY
USB extender: https://amzn.to/41bY0Jn
I also have a Home Assistant SkyConnect plugged in but I’m still using Zigbee and Z-Wave devices so I haven’t used it outside of testing: https://www.home-assistant.io/skyconnect/
Home Assistant Yellow: https://www.home-assistant.io/yellow/
Home Assistant Green: https://www.home-assistant.io/green/
Pixel Tablet with the Home Assistant dashboard I’m using: https://howl.me/cjZ0hLVy62I
(affiliate links)
More about Alexa vs Siri vs Google, watch this: https://youtu.be/ZkuKvYQQjlg?si=kGluJ5mcI2HK0Sem
More about Google Script Editor: https://youtu.be/CaDGz8S7dvY?si=LgB8WHGc2vEl3X8e
My smart home favorites: https://www.amazon.com/shop/smarthomesolver
FOLLOW ME
Subscribe to Smart Home Solver: https://bit.ly/3joO1dZ
Subscribe to Reed’s Smart Home: http://bit.ly/3EulO02
Twitter: https://twitter.com/SmartHomeSolver
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/smarthomesolver/
TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@smarthomesolver
0:00 Intro
0:15 Too many systems 😬
1:32 On the chopping block
3:13 Best user-friendly system
4:53 Best hub (the brains)
8:17 My HA setup
9:47 Home Assistant Time Warp
———
MUSIC
All of the music throughout is by Nihilore.
Spotify playlist: https://open.spotify.com/playlist/7LVYQYkdLFkkpJiGdkzX9K
Ending song is The End by EVA.
https://open.spotify.com/artist/6UIs5b0zSXztIW5GHkCTkK
What if the house is split between Apple and Google? I can’t wait until Linux phones are stable and all this nonsense can be a thing of the past 🤷🤦
Edit: I love these videos, they’re to the point with detail, family friendly and bonus dad jokes 👍
OK HA – what thermostat do you recommend? Need to fix asap! What do I buy?
Im struggling as I have two homes. I use Google in CA, but I am struggling with what to do in CO.
Google is terrible. Basically Google = no privacy and stolen data. Apple may be ok, but I have an Android phone. Apples phone just suck. Home Assistant is OK.
My question is, what other system can I use that works with eufy cameras, and Android phones, that’s not Google or Apple, but is still private?
That one question is what’s holding me back from going nuts with Smart Home tech.
Reed, with LG buying Homey do you think it will go down hill like it did with Samsung Smarthings. I currently have Smarthings and want to switch but don’t want to make the same mistake. Thanks
Who is this guy?
You should try out Homey Pro 2023 👍 Its both Easy to use and connects to almost everything.
If you were to buy smart light switches for your house today, which ones would you choose?
Can you list all the items you talked about with price and where to buy?
New to this entire field. What kinds of things do you automate that are truly worth the set-up and that you don’t really to do yourself?
Is Apple really bound to support their ecosystem longer than Google? I feel like that’s hard to argue. Apple is rather notorious for employing business practices that highly encourage if not outright force you to need to upgrade to the newest model within a couple of short years. The lawsuit they were hit with over their bad battery life as well as throttling performance on phones 2 years and olfer "to save battery" is an obvious example that comes to mind. The other thing with Apple is that everything they sell is locked into a proprietary ecosystem, and except for some uncommon exceptions, once you go Apple, you kind of have to stay Apple or be prepared to replace a LOT of different tech all in a short timeframe. Obviously, Apple Home seems to be the biggest exception to this with a surprisingly diverse selection of compatible 3rd party hardware and accessories options. However, what happens if Apple does discontinue their support of Apple Home? What if they simply stop supporting the Apple Home OS version you have, and you’re unable to update it unless you upgrade your hardware to the next generation of products? You would be forced to switch ecosystems or just buy all that new hardware. The thing with Google is that even though they might not offer software, OS, and technical support for their products to the same degree that Apple does, Google’s software and OS are ultimately open source, or it is at most a slightly modified version of their base open source software/OS. So, even if Google were to scrap the Google Home product line and software sweet completely, there would still be software/firmware/OS support for the (now) legacy hardware via 3rd party online communities such as individuals or groups on GitHub or even small non-profit organizations of developers who jump in as one option among potentially very many similar to the Linux community and the common way that Linux distros are almost all developed by non-profit developer organizations that operate entirely off of donations. This fundamental difference between Apple and Google is what leads me to feel that even though Apple’s official support of their products has a very real chance of being supported for a longer extent of time than Google’a official support of their products, high quality, professional quality support in general is almost certainly greater with Google products once you consider the difference in their basic business philosophies concerning their proprietary versus open source natures.
Maybe a stupid question but can Home Assistant change interface based on in which room you are in with MMwave/bluetooth?
Nice video
Any thoughts on the Aqara Hubs?
Only problem is Apple Home Kit is only for Apple Users. You can’t get that app on an Android, which over 60% of the U.S use. So what’s the "BEST" smart home system for a house with both Android AND Apple users? I think that’s probably a more likely scenario then a house filled with one ecosystem. Had me going though.
smart home system
Have you had a chance to get your hands on the LinkNLink iSG?
Privacy? 😂😂😂😂😂😂 Do you remember the photo roll back of deleted photos that apple mistakenly revealed after ios update? 😂😂😂😂😂
I’m a very competent nerd. I learnt VBA to automate tasks in Microsoft Office/365. I have dabbled in video game dev. I have a fully bespoke and custom KWLP launcher integrated with Nova Launcher on my Android and it’s better for me than any launcher in existence. If you aren’t familiar with KLWP then look it up because it is a lot of effort and all front end ui-based dev via the phone only – so it’s very tedious and intensive.
So I’m happy to jump through some hoops for automation and convenience/perceived convenience.
Yet, even with you making Smart Home tech sound as simple and easy possible… It’s clear that it’s entirely just a waste of money.
Its a thinly veiled gimmick to get subscription money and extra sellable user data.
Even PC RGB lighting isn’t dependent on ecosystem mechanics anymore, not like smart homes are.
Every piece of smart hardware is prohibitively expensive, and adds up fast. Requires extensive fiddling to get working and then reportedly fails to work in perpetuity…
All so you can use your phone instead of getting up (an oversimplification I know).
Smart devices should be half their price, not come with privacy invading strings, and just work. It’s been over a decade since Hue came to market now. No excuse.
Now, do one thats not sponsored by apple
I went with HomeAssistant + HomeKit.
My sus smart home system
I’m a novice when it comes to smart homes, although I have a few bits. One thing I can’t seem to do (which I apparently should be able to) is to transfer my media between my google nest speakers. Could I circumvent Google by using home assistant if I were to add that does anyone know please? It was actually the reason I wanted smart speakers to begin with and I’ve never been able to get it to work!
There’s no sensible response from google regarding this. It’s like talking to a brick wall. I’ve been looking at Alexa/amazon, but as this video explains, adding subscriptions to everything is a big no no.
I don’t really know where to ask so if anyone responds, thank a lot!
is this still accurate?
Great content,
I was wondering why didn’t you go to docker installation of HA, while trying to make a user management features and add whatever you want to your home
I still don’t get how they "work together". You add devises in HA then import them to HK. Can you do that for automations?
Homepods are fine if you like low volume. When I still was using Apple, I couldn’t get enough volume out of the Homepod Mini for it to be useful. And, yes. Siri is not very good, but it sure is chatty!
It would be great if Youtubers would stop speaking in a tonality that someone would use when they’re talking to a group of children.
can I just install home assistant on my tablet? or do I need a physical hard drive?
I love the skit. I’ll look at using it with Google. Anything that ties you to a specific platform is a non-starter.
If I ask Google to start a second timer while keeping the first one it just goes dump and cannot do it. Smart whatever is far from entering my home at this rate.
Im here because i simply want cheap water leak detectors and entry sensors. I found some that use WiFi and simple SmartLife app but heard about Zigbee having significantly less power consumption for said battery powered devices. So.. I buy a zigbee hub, then what? I dont just simply connect it (a sonoff dongle for example) to any usb port on my computer, do I?
Stan AleXa Copyers
lol that outro was gold 😂
i felt this deeply
Crestron custom? Crestron Home? Control4? Money can buy a lot more than these cheap DIY systems. You’ll never see this off the shelf stuff in a high end home.
I have a phone and tablet – android no computer. Say I buy home assistant. And have google home. What do I do tell me like I’m a idiot cause I haven’t found a video yet that makes sense. As an example I open the front door of my house and music plays from Spotify on my sonas and my Wiz lights go into certain setting. How do I do that ?
Hope this helped clear up any confusion on what I use! Another smart home tour coming soon, so make sure you’re subscribed 👏
I personally use HA and Google
I would really love to see how you would use Google Home with Home assistant for us android users.
So where’s the video about getting going with home Zlassist
Have you tried Universal Devices EISY hub? Integrates everything (even old Insteon).
I want to leave Amazon. I was thinking of
Google. I have started the transition.
Question will probably not get answered however what’s your preference for a Zigbee Dongle and what software are your running on the Zigbee Dongle?
Agree with home assistant. 👍
Amazing visuals and clear explanations, this is top-notch content! 8:20
Question: what WiFi router or routers would you recommend for Apple HomeKit these days? Thanks!
Lol, nope. Never using Apple.
Have you tried Fibaro? It’s a polish company and it’s z-wave based! HIGHLY RECOMMENDED!!
Is smartthings planning on bringing back advanced features?